Peer Online Course Review
Peer Online Course Review (POCR) is a rigorous system that leverages the CVC Rubric for high-quality online course design, originally established in a partnership by the CCC Chancellor’s, CVC@ONE, and ASCCC. The processes included in Chaffey College’s local POCR system include Academy, Alignment, Reviewers, and Badging, and the courses that undergo the Alignment process receive a Quality Reviewed badge on the CVC Exchange.
POCR Academy
In this Chaffey College professional development, you will receive the CVC Rubric and practice implementing parts of it with guidance from trained facilitators. This is an excellent way to kickstart the alignment process.
Eligible Faculty
- Faculty must have a class assignment when participating in Fall or Spring terms (this policy does not apply in the summer term).
Process Overview
- There are two modalities of POCR Academy offered throughout the year according to faculty learning preferences: Synchronous Zoom sessions (with no in-person meetings) or facilitated asynchronous coursework through Canvas.
- Both modalities cover the same content, are offered in a three-week format, and are compensated in the same structure.
- During Spring or Fall terms, first-time faculty participants may have the choice of 8 hours of Flex credit or 8 hours of payment at the seminar rate of $25/hour.
- Any faculty repeating the training in Spring or Fall terms are only eligible to receive Flex credit.
- During the Summer term, this professional development is limited to paid participants only.
Getting Involved
- POCR Academy is offered twice in Fall and Spring terms and once in the Summer term; faculty may sign up through My Learning Hub.
- If you have questions, contact the POCR Lead, Ryan Hitch.
POCR Alignment
POCR Alignment is the facilitated process of a faculty fully aligning their course with the CVC Rubric to incorporate best practices in online course design, interaction, and accessibility to support student success. At Chaffey College, our local POCR Alignment process has been validated as an equity driver through a 2022 IR study and 2025 IR study.
Eligible Courses
- Fully Online Course
- Credit Course
- Course Taught: Last Academic Year, This Semester, or Next Semester
Process Overview
- This asynchronous process must take place in one semester.
- POCR Alignment requires complete alignment with all four sections of the CVC Rubric: Content Presentation, Interaction, Assessment, and Accessibility.
- This work is facilitated by the POCR Lead, Ryan Hitch, and supported by the DE Team inside a shared Canvas Sandbox shell.
- The final review to ensure POCR Alignment is supported by two anonymous POCR Reviewers from within Chaffey College but outside your discipline.
Getting Involved
- Recruitment for POCR Alignment occurs via campuswide email one semester prior to alignment work.
- If you have questions, contact the POCR Lead, Ryan Hitch.
POCR Reviewer Training
The CVC@ONE provides Peer Online Course Review (POCR) Reviewer Training to members of local POCR teams at California Community Colleges. This is an advanced course designed for experienced online educators who are preparing to review courses using the CVC Course Design Rubric. Successful participants will develop strategies to offer collegial, rubric-based, actionable feedback to their peers.
Eligible Faculty
- @ONE coursework and/or local training in online course design and facilitation, or experience teaching in Canvas, is strongly recommended as preparation for this fast-paced, intensive training.
Process Overview
- POCR Reviewer Training is six weeks of asynchronous online coursework, estimated by CVC@ONE to be approximately 10 hours per week.
- Upon successful completion, faculty join Chaffey College’s local POCR team.
- POCR Reviewers are expected to attend one CVC-led POCR Norming Session via Zoom once a year.
- POCR Reviewers receive additional compensation for each anonymous peer review they complete of a faculty aligner’s work.
Getting Involved
- Recruitment for POCR Reviewer Training occurs via campuswide email once every three years in the fall prior to spring training opportunities hosted by CVC@ONE.
- If you have questions, contact the POCR Lead, Ryan Hitch.
POCR Badging Across Institutions
Are you teaching a POCR-Aligned course that you already aligned at another institution? Chaffey College wants to recognize your quality online work! Submit a request to badge the same course at Chaffey College by completing the POCR Badge Request form.
Upon successful completion of the form, the Chaffey College course you teach that was POCR-aligned at another institution will show up with a “Quality Reviewed” badge when you teach it here at Chaffey College as well.
Plug and Play Adoptable Courses
CVC@ONE has developed Plug and Play Adoptable Courses to support faculty:
- Exploring examples of online teaching.
- Preparing to teach a new course shell with little lead time.
- Ensuring accessible online experiences for students.
- Maintaining space for faculty personalization and customization.
These Plug and Play course templates provide faculty adopters with a solid online resource. Each course is aligned with the CVC Rubric where possible, developed with OER material, and made to be fully accessible.
What Plug and Play Is
- An excellent template for what an accessible online course could look like.
- Inspiration for how to leverage OER in each respective course.
- A guide new instructors can turn to when teaching a course for the first time.
- Pre-made template with opportunities for personalization and customization.
What Plug and Play Is Not
- A barrier that prevents faculty from uploading inaccessible content.
- An obstacle to requiring textbooks or other material.
- An authority on teaching; it has been built to be altered.
- A replacement for faculty-led instruction.
Which Courses Are Available For Adoption?
CVC@ONE is developing Plug and Play to follow the statewide Common Course Numbering (CCN) schedule. At this time, the following courses are available:
- COMM C1000: Introduction to Public Speaking
- ENGL C1000: Academic Reading and Writing
- ENGL C1001: Critical Thinking and Writing
- STAT C1000: Introduction to Statistics
- PSYC C1000: Introduction to Psychology
Additionally courses in Political Science, History, Art History, English, and Economics are in development over the next year.
How Can I Adopt a Course?
- All of the Plug and Play courses are posted to the CCC Commons Consortium. To access them, you will need to log into your college Canvas account and click on the “Commons” button located on the left side global navigation column.
- Uncheck the “Chaffey College” filter from beneath your search bar. Then, search for “CVC Plug and Play.”
- Once you find a course, select “Import/Download.”
- Select “Import into Canvas” and locate the appropriate Sandbox shell.
Note: We recommend importing into a Sandbox shell first because whether you simply want to explore, use various pieces of the course, or adopt the entire course, there is a level of personalization and customization required before any part of the Plug and Play course template would be ready for a live course. - Select “Import into Course”
- Go to your Sandbox shell, and start personalizing it!
Frequently Asked Questions
While Chaffey College DE praises any work that faculty do to align their online courses with the CVC Rubric, we believe the most equitable and effective approach to POCR Alignment is a facilitated one. If you believe you are close to a fully aligned course, we encourage you to stop your alignment work and contact the POCR Lead, Ryan Hitch, to learn how to apply for the next round of facilitated POCR Alignments so you can get compensated for your work.
As long as your course is fully online, offered for credit, and something you have taught in the last academic year, are teaching this semester, or will teach in the upcoming term, you are welcome to apply for POCR Alignment with that course.
Section D of the CVC Rubric requires full course accessibility. LTIs and publisher material, ranging from lecture slides to external courses like MindTap or Inquizitive, can sometimes present accessibility challenges that are difficult or impossible for the individual faculty to remediate (because they don’t own the material). Consequently, we ask about these elements in the interest form to learn about how they may affect the POCR Alignment process.
Once the faculty aligner believes they have fully aligned their eligible course in this facilitated process, the POCR Lead coordinates with two anonymous POCR Reviewers outside that aligner’s discipline to review that assertion of alignment and provide feedback. This is meant to mimic the student experience of someone outside the discipline navigating the course and course material.
Once you have completed the six week CVC@ONE POCR Reviewer Training course, there are two ongoing responsibilities. The first responsibility is a once-a-year obligation to attend one two-hour CVC-led POCR Norming Session via Zoom. Multiple sessions are announced each year on different days months in advance. The second responsibility is a recurring and paid optional opportunity to review courses that faculty aligners have worked on with the POCR Lead and DE Team.
While Chaffey College’s local POCR Academy is not required for POCR Reviewer Training or Alignment, faculty may find it beneficial and most beneficial to take first in the sequence.
The systemwide norm is for faculty to get compensated for POCR Alignment at the institution where that alignment work occurred. However, the systemwide norm is that the “Quality Reviewed” badge which demonstrates the faculty’s online excellence stays at that institution as well, and we believe that isn’t right. Faculty do great work everywhere they teach. Thus, we designed a form that provides us the information we need to badge your course locally with the least amount of additional work from you.
Contact us
Rancho Campus
- (909) 652-6975
- onlineed@chaffey.edu
- LLC-214B
- Hours:
Monday – Friday
8:00 am – 4:00pm
