Textbook Transformation Project
[UPBEAT MUSIC] ROBIN WITT: Think about
how cool it would be. On day one of your course,
every student has the book. They're ready to learn. SANDRA: I've actually
been in classes where there were students
that weren't in a place that they were able to
afford really expensive medical textbooks and stuff. And it was kind of a bummer
because those students just weren't able to
thrive in the same way that other students
were able to. So having access to
zero-cost textbooks, I think it's more equitable. TARA JOHNSON: It's
heart-wrenching to see a student at the
beginning of the semester that you know is going to be
less successful because they can't get it right away, or
they just can't get it period. ANTHONY GUARACHA:
Sometimes, students have sent me emails in a
class that I hadn't adopted ZTC sharing that they weren't
able to afford a textbook-- things are tight right now. And so that really
resonated with me. And that's a plus
for instructors, too, so that way they
can-- the students can get started on the
content and not have to worry and stress about
whether that they can continue at the college. STEPHANIE: I was
paying a lot of money. And then, I started
going, whoa, I can only take one
course at a time because it didn't allow
me to finish up quicker by all this expense. PHATANA ITH: I think
that the benefit for a student who is taking a
ZTC class, first and foremost, is access. EMILY: I would say
it's easy to access. I can access it on my phone. CHUNYAN: It saves me
money, saves me time, makes me learn better and learn more. MARIA: It's more personal
with the professor, versus a textbook. It's just like handed work-- like here you go, read it, and
then kind of learn on your own. But with zero-cost
textbook courses, I feel like you have
more digging to do. SANDRA: I think I
actually like it better than a traditional text
because with the zero-cost textbooks, I feel like the
professor really takes the care to really structure the
material around the course. IAN JONES: Beyond just the money
aspects and the frustration is also the fact that
the professors that use ZTC tend to supplement
their courses with more on-the-spot texts students
need throughout the semester. So I think it changes
the professor's pedagogy in a way that benefits students. CHARLES WILLIAMS: So there's
this problem with diversity in the textbooks. And what the ZTC
process allows you to do is to structure the course the
way you want to structure it. You don't have to be
concerned about the math and representation. You can just pick
the best writers. JACKSON TROPP: I think there
are a multitude of benefits to using ZTC materials
for instructors. One, I think, is course design. Designing a course
is a lot of work. But with ZTC materials,
it can be less work, and it can feel more
personal to you. Right? You can curate
what you want based on the themes that
you want to teach, based on your course
outline record. Right? But you get to determine
how you teach that material. ANTHONY GUARACHA: Also,
looking at the data, being informed about the data
how students who utilize ZTC have greater retention
and success rates. SANDRA: You should use
zero-cost textbooks.
[LAUGHS] CHUNYAN: If two sections
are both available for me, of course I will choose
the zero textbook. PHATANA ITH: In addition
to the extrinsic reward of having your class
listed as ZTC-- having the persuasive
appeal of a student being drawn to your class
because it requires less financial resource for
them to take this class-- the very intrinsic reward
is we're providing access and we're providing a
legacy for a student to develop knowledge, hone
in on their own power, and be that resource for them. STEPHANIE: The most
important thing for me saving
money of not buying texts was to help my children
become students of a college and pay for their education. TARA JOHNSON: I think
the hesitancy is more the unknown, that it's scary. But once you dive
in, and once you do it and you see the outcomes
for your students, you're like, oh, why didn't I do this sooner? MARIA: I would want
more of them to do it because you can't be opposed
to something you haven't tried. So if you give it a chance,
and it plays out where students like it, then why not do it? ROBIN WITT: Zero-cost options
are becoming more popular. And there's more and
more options every day, so don't give up. JACKSON TROPP: I promise
that once you get started, there are so many resources
not only in the material, but in the people that
you work with as well. HANNAH LUCAS: Check out what
we're doing with the Textbook Transformation Project
because we have really tried to create accessible,
convenient, but also comprehensive course
shelves now that make it so much easier to adopt. IAN JONES: I love
Chaffey because there's the spirit of sharing and
student-centric teaching here. So if we all band
together-- share, promote-- we'll get there eventually.
[UPBEAT MUSIC]
Mission Statement:
Chaffey College's Textbook Transformation Project is a faculty-led and faculty-inspired
institutional commitment to expand Zero-Cost Textbook options, courses, GE pathways, and
degrees that advocate for the success, retention, and generational achievement of students
of color and all students.
Textbook Transformation Project Overview
Media player


70%
70%, Click to access volume slider
0:00 / 6:37Speed: 1x
[MUSIC PLAYING] SPEAKER: Zero-cost
textbook initiatives are happening across
California Community Colleges and through the state
legislature in important ways to promote student
success and retention. Chaffey College is leading these
initiatives with the Textbook Transformation Project. This video is meant to introduce
the campus to what the Textbook Transformation Project
has been working on so far, future goals,
the student impact, and how to get involved in
this important initiative. But to start, what do
these terms even mean? ZTC stands for
Zero Textbook Cost. The term ZTC is a
course designation showcasing that a course
uses materials that are completely free to users. OER stands for Open
Educational Resources. OER material falls under
the ZTC umbrella term and is a course
designation showcasing that a course utilizes
materials that are free but also open access. LCT refers to Low Cost Textbook. A course is
designated as LCT when it uses materials that have
a combined total cost that is $50 or less. That includes books,
homework, websites, software, lab manuals-- all of it, under $50 total. Courses can also have
the designation of NTR meaning No Textbook Required. This is used when courses
do not have an assigned textbook or any other
bound educational resources associated with it. NTR material also falls
under the ZTC umbrella term. The traditional
textbook model is one a course uses
materials that amount to a total cost above $50. As research has shown, the
traditional textbook model creates barriers to
access for students that result in inequitable
educational experiences and decreases student success. So why is this
beneficial to students? Courses that utilize
ZTC materials have been proven to benefit
students success in learning outcomes, accessibility
to materials, retention in higher education,
and higher engagement in course material. Student voices have propelled
the zero textbook cost initiatives across the state. Students thrive in
classes that use zero and low-cost textbooks, stating
it alleviates complications, helps them stay organized,
and maximizes their time and efficiency. Students of color are
more likely to take on majors that seem out of
reach because of program costs within STEM
fields, and women are more likely to
enter the workforce at faster rates due to earning
higher degrees through ZTC degree pathways. This is why Chaffey is committed
to the Textbook Transformation Project. The Textbook
Transformation Project team has identified key
high-impact courses across seven departments, and
from three academic and career communities for
its first cohort. Over the course of the fall
2021 semester, focus groups were held with
full-time faculties from each of the
seven departments to evaluate course materials
needs and impressions on ZTC material. In addition, an anonymous
survey was sent out to the entire department
to better understand how to facilitate zero or
low-cost textual options for these key courses.
This semester, Spring
of 2022, a [? FOSO ?] will be disseminated
looking for TTP coaches to serve
as the discipline experts in these seven
departments to pilot the zero and low-cost materials in
those specific courses. There will be a
spring a ZTC challenge to in collaboration with DE. In addition, we'll be
creating a ZTC certification that faculty can participate
in across the disciplines. Soon after piloting material
in these seven courses, we will transition to
cohort two and so on, continuing to work
alongside discipline experts to identify and utilize
course materials that fit within the zero
or low-cost model. The Textbook Transformation
Project has two ultimate goals. The first, to create
ZTC degree pathways where students can walk
away with a Chaffey degree with little to no
course material costs. The second is to create what we
are calling TTP super courses, courses that utilize zero
and low-cost textbooks to advocate for the
success, retention, and generational achievement
of students of color and all students, select
and create accessible course materials, are focused
on student impact and present a diverse
representation of voices, build in equity-based
assessment tools by integrating ACEs and
ILOs, build material that meets the universal design
of learning to facilitate student-centered approach,
and have materials that are transitional
between face-to-face, distance education, hybrid,
and everything in between. So how can you get involved? Well, you can start by
learning more about OER and ZTC and even low-cost textbooks
options through the Spring DE challenge. Once the certification
modules are up and running, get ZTC certified. You can apply to
become a TTP coach. When we come to your departments
either in this cohort or future cohorts, participate
in our focus groups. Complete the anonymous
surveys, and help us out. Each of your voices and
discipline expertise is vital to the success
of this project. We want to remind you that your
participation in this project is completely optional
and up to each of you. Retaining academic
freedom is extremely important to all of us. However, with all of the
data showing all of the ways that this helps
students, the question is not why you should do
this, but why shouldn't you be doing this? Advocacy is an action. The choices are yours.
[MUSIC PLAYING]
ZTC : Zero Textbook Cost
Course uses materials (textbooks, workbooks, articles, library resources, software/hardware,
supplies, etc.) that are free to users. Total material costs for the course are $0.
Course materials that are open access through Creative Commons, OER, and courses that
have no assigned materials fall under the ZTC model.
LCT: Low-Cost Textbooks
Course uses materials where the combined total cost of all required materials (textbooks,
workbooks, articles, library resources, software/hardware, supplies, etc.) is $50
or less.
Traditional Textbook Model
(Textbooks &/Or Materials Above $50)
Course uses materials (textbooks, workbooks, manuals, software/hardware, supplies,
homework websites, etc.) that amount to a total cost $50.
Barriers to Access
(Access Codes/Publisher Subscriptions)
Course uses material through an access code/publisher subscription that allows access
during a set period of time. If a student needs to pay fees to access a software platform
to do coursework or homework, this counts as a cost. This does not fall under the
"ZTC" model because they inherently create barriers to information.
The Textbook Transformation Project has two ultimate goals:
- To create ZTC degree pathways, to help students fulfill general education without
material costs.
- To support faculty in intentionally aligning many of our campus-wide equity initiatives,
including:
- Utilizing ZTC/LCT to advocate for the success, retention, and generational achievement
of students of color and all students.
- Selecting and creating accessible course materials.
- Presenting a diverse representation of voices
- Building in equity-based assessment tools by integrating ACEs/ILOs
- Building material that meets the Universal Design of learning to facilitate a student-centered
approach
- Having materials that are transitional between multiple modalities.

TTP COHORT 1 COURSES
The first Cohort of Textbook Transformation Project courses were chosen because they
represent the highest impacted student enrollments. These departments have made ZTC/LCT
commitments in support of equitable and successful outcomes for students, particularly
those from historically excluded and/or disproportionately impacted communities. Cohort
#1 includes BIOL 20, COMSTD 2, ENGL 1A, MATH 25, PSYCH 1, SOC 10, SPAN 1, GUID 2 AND
GUID 3.
Textbook Transformation Project Impact
ZTC/LTC - Advocating for the success, retention, and generational achievement of students
of color and all students
ACES/ILO - Building in equity-based assessment tools.
Pathway to POCR - Building material that meets Universal Design of Learning to facilitate
a student-centered approach to learning.
Multi-modal Pedagogy - Materials that are transitional between FTF, DE, Hybrid, Hyflex,
etc.
Equity - Student impact, diverse representation of voices.
Accessibility - Selecting and creating accessible course materials.